Skip to main content

Compare
|
Gift Certificates
Sign in or Register
Cart

Search

Search

Candy Type
- All Candy Type
- Limited Edition
  - Candies
  - Sales
- Marshmallow
- No Sugar Added
- Seeds, Nuts, Berries
- Sucker
- Kosher
  - Hard Candy Parve
- Caramel & Toffee
- Cookies
- Imported Gourmet
- Lollipops and Suckers
- Mellocreme
- Milk Chocolate
- PEZ
- Pop Rocks
- Dubble Bubble
- Sour Candy
- Throat Drops
- Chewy Candy
- Chocolate Gourmet Candy
- Taffy
  - Laffy Taffy®
  - Salt Water Taffy
- Gummi
- Rock Candy
- Hard Candy
- Insect Candy
- Hotlix
- Gum
- Wax
- Gumballs
- Frooties
- Licorice
- Jawbreakers
  - Atomic Fireballs
- Mints
- Dextrose
- Nostalgic
- Sugar Free
- Kids' Favorites
Discontinued
- All Discontinued
- Fizzies
Candy Occasion
Candy Flavor
- All Candy Flavor
- Almond
- Cookie & Creme
- Anise
- Apple
- Banana
- Berry
- Birthday Cake
- Black Cherry
- Black Licorice
- Blackberry
- Blue Rasberry
- Blueberry
- Bourbon
- BubbleGum
- Butter
- Butter Rum
- Butterscotch
- caramel
- Cherry
- Chocolate
- Cinnamon
- Citrus
- Clove
- Coconut
- Coffee/Espresso
- Cola
- Cotton Candy
- Cran-Blueberry
- Dark Chocolate
- Fruit Flavored/Assorted Flavors
- Ginger
- Grape
- Green Apple
- Honey
- Horehound
- Kiwi
- Lemon
- Lemon-Lime
- Licorice
- Lime
- Lychee
- Mango
- Maple
- Mello Creme
- Milk Chocolate
- Mint
- Molasses
- Molasses
- Muscat
- Orange
- Original Dubble Bubble Flavor
- Passion Fruit
- Peach
- Peanut Butter
- Peppermint
- Pepsin
- Pina Colada
- Pineapple
- Pink Grapefruit
- Plum
- Pumpkin Pie
- Punch
- Ramune
- Raspberry
- Root Beer
- S'mores
- Sassafras
- Sour
- Spearment
- Strawberry
- Strawberry Banana
- Strawberry-Lemonade
- Sugar/Dextrose
- Tropical
- Vanilla
- Violet
- Watermelon
- Wintergreen
Candy Color
- All Candy Color
- Assorted
- Autumn and Fall
- Black
- Blue
- Brown
- Cream
- Dark Brown
- Gold
- Green
- Hot Pink
- Lavender
- Orange
- Pastel
- Peach
- Pearl Silver
- Pearl White
- Pink
- Primary Colors
- Purple
- Red
- Silver
- Tan
- White
- Yellow
About us
Blog
Contact Us
Shipping & Returns

Gift Certificates
Sign in or Register

Home
Candy Flavor
Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter

Shop By Price

Enter the minimum price to filter products by

Enter the maximum price to filter products by

Reset The filter has been reset

Sort By:

Compare

Custom Candies

Ground Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Ice Cream Topping 1LB (453g) Custom

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $11.59

!

Footer Start

Connect With Us

Navigate

About us
Blog
Contact Us
Shipping & Returns
Sitemap

Categories

Candy Type
Discontinued
Candy Occasion
Candy Flavor
Candy Color

Popular Brands

Zachary
jELLY bELLY
Concord®
My M&M's
Albanese®
Claey's
Smarties®
Primrose®
Spangler
Gerrit
View All

Info

954 Phillips Ave.
Toledo, Oh 43612

Call us at 1-419-720-7387

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the latest updates on new products and upcoming sales

Email Address

© 2025 Boyd's Retro Candy Store Store